The McCoy pottery company produced a range of charming and collectible cookie jars, and among the most sought-after is the iconic Smiley Face cookie jar. These cheerful ceramics bring a touch of vintage whimsy to any kitchen, and their value continues to grow among collectors. This guide will explore everything you need to know about McCoy Smiley Face cookie jars, helping you identify genuine pieces, understand their value, and appreciate their history.
What Makes McCoy Smiley Face Cookie Jars So Collectible?
Several factors contribute to the high collectibility of McCoy Smiley Face cookie jars. Firstly, their retro appeal is undeniable. The simple yet expressive smiley face design evokes a sense of nostalgia and happy memories, resonating with collectors who appreciate mid-century modern aesthetics. Secondly, their quality craftsmanship is evident in the sturdy construction and detailed painting. While mass-produced, each jar exhibits a unique character. Finally, their rarity, particularly for certain variations and conditions, drives up their value in the collector's market.
Identifying Authentic McCoy Smiley Face Cookie Jars
Distinguishing genuine McCoy Smiley Face cookie jars from reproductions or imitations is crucial. Look for these key features:
- Markings: Authentic McCoy jars will typically have a McCoy Pottery mark, often a simple "McCoy" or a more elaborate logo. The location and style of the mark can vary depending on the production period. Examine the mark carefully, as counterfeit jars often have inaccurate or poorly executed markings.
- Glaze: McCoy pottery is known for its distinctive glaze, often characterized by its smoothness and evenness. Irregularities or a poorly applied glaze can indicate a reproduction.
- Colors: While variations exist, McCoy Smiley Face jars typically feature a consistent palette of yellows, oranges, and browns. Unusual or faded colors should raise concerns.
- Shape and Size: Pay attention to the jar's overall shape and size. While variations in size are possible, significant deviations from the known typical dimensions might suggest a fake.
How Much Are McCoy Smiley Face Cookie Jars Worth?
The value of a McCoy Smiley Face cookie jar is highly variable and depends on several factors, including:
- Condition: The jar's condition is paramount. Minor chips, cracks, or crazing will significantly reduce its value. A pristine, undamaged jar in its original box will command the highest price.
- Rarity: Certain color variations or variations in the smiley face design are rarer than others, increasing their value.
- Demand: Current market demand plays a significant role in determining the price. A high demand will drive prices up.
You can find estimated values through online auction sites and collector's forums. However, it's best to consult with an experienced appraiser for an accurate valuation of a specific jar.
What Colors Were McCoy Smiley Face Cookie Jars Made In?
McCoy Smiley Face cookie jars came in a variety of colors, though yellow is probably the most common. Other colors include different shades of orange, brown, and even variations incorporating other accent colors. The precise shade and color combination can impact the jar's value and collectibility. The variations in color, while fairly subtle, are of particular interest to serious collectors.
Are McCoy Smiley Face Cookie Jars Still Made?
No, the McCoy pottery company is no longer in operation, meaning that no new McCoy Smiley Face cookie jars are being produced. This limited supply further contributes to their collectability and value. Any “new” jars are almost certainly reproductions.
Where Can I Find a McCoy Smiley Face Cookie Jar?
You can find McCoy Smiley Face cookie jars in a variety of places, including:
- Online auction sites: eBay and similar platforms are common places to find these jars.
- Antique shops and flea markets: These locations are great places to find unique and often undervalued items.
- Collectible shows: Dedicated collectible shows can be excellent hunting grounds for rare and valuable items.
- Online collector's forums: These forums can be great places to connect with other collectors and potentially find jars for sale.
Remember to always carefully inspect any potential purchase before buying to ensure its authenticity and condition.
By understanding the characteristics of genuine McCoy Smiley Face cookie jars and the factors influencing their value, you can confidently navigate the world of collecting and acquire a truly cherished piece of pottery history.
